When Should You Increase Insurance Deductibles?

Print Friendly

Insurance is your financial defense.

Insurance is not an optional component of a good financial plan because if you cut this corner, you expose yourself to too much risk.  In fact, not having an appropriate amount of insurance can cause serious financial damage.

However, one way to minimize the insurance pinch is to consider increasing your insurance deductibles.

Insurance Deductible Quick Review

The deductible is the portion of your insurance that you are required to pay when there is a claim.  For example, if your car coverage has a $500 deductible, that means you will pay the first $500 if there is a claim.

The Insurance Deductible and Premiums Teeter Totter

There is always a parallel relationship between deductibles and premiums.

The higher the deductible, the the lower the premium. The lower the deductible, the higher the premium.  You cannot have your cake and eat it too.

When one goes up, the other must come down.

To illustrate, I went to eHealthInsurance (affiliate link).  Before buying international health insurance, I had purchased my last policy through eHealthHnsurance.  I entered my actual family information and selected Blue Cross Blue Shield (I used to have BCBS health insurance) for their PPO Select Plan Saver IV (not a recommendation, but a selection).

Using that example, I got the following results:

Deductible $2,500 = Premium $377 monthly

Deductible $5,000 = Premium $290 monthly

By increasing my deductible by $2,500 annually, I could save $87.00 per month or $1044 per year.  That would be a great idea, as long as you are in a financial position to be able to increase your deductible.

Should You Increase Your Insurance Deductible?

The following questions can apply to all sorts of coverage: health, auto, renters, and home insurance.  How you answer the question impacts if you should increase your insurance deductible.

Question #1: Are you low risk?

For health coverage, ask yourself: is my family relatively healthy?  If yes, you are low risk.

In my case, other than medical bills when my wife has had a baby, we have never even come close to our deductible in the last 10 years.

If you are applying for health insurance, review your records over the last five years.  If you have not reached your deductible 3 out of 5 years, you could probably consider increasing your insurance deductible.  More often than that, and it might not make financial sense.

If you are talking about auto coverage and you have a teenager whom you do not trust, you might need to keep a higher deductible. And don’t forget to pray.

Question #2: Are you and your children responsible?

Insurance money is not a waste of money.  Nor is insurance a way to get rich quick.  It is simply a way to be sure you are financially progressing.  Insurance allows you to move forward without the risk of sliding backwards.

When you increase your insurance deductibles, in some ways you do increase your risk.  As such, be sure that, for example, teens in the house understand the importance of safe driving.

If you are a responsible person, it will be reflected in your insurance.  Non-smokers pay less for life insurance.  Teens with better grades pay less for auto insurance.  Adults with better FICO scores pay less for insurance.

Question #3: Do you have double your highest deductible in an emergency fund?

Let’s say you’re thinking about increasing your health insurance to a $5,000 deductible.  In this case, you would need to be sure you have at least $10,000 in an emergency fund.

Should it be double the sum of all your insurance deductibles?

No, I don’t think so.  I’m assuming you won’t reach your deductible on your auto insurance, house insurance, and health insurance all in the same year.

For this reason, if you are in good financial shape and you double your highest deductible, you can cover it from your emergency fund.

Note: Technically, for a family you might have a total payout limit of $15,000, (deductible of three family members) so you should have at least $30,000 in an emergency fund.  However, the likelihood (if healthy) of three family members all reaching their deductible in the same year is quite slim.  As a result, use the double a single deductible as a guide.

Special note to those in debt:

Those in debt will need to do a little extra math here.  Most likely, you will be better off keeping a minimal emergency fund, regular deductibles, and paying off your debt.  However, if your insurance savings are dramatic enough, you could consider putting your debt repayment on hold while you built up an emergency fund so that you could increase insurance deductibles.

Since your case is fact dependent, you will need to run your own numbers on this one, but I think you will be better off focusing on your debt.

Keep your emergency fund in an account without risk.

Since your emergency fund now has a backup insurance role, you need to be extra sure that these funds are safe.  Just realize the return you are getting on these funds is as much what they are saving you in premiums as what you are getting in interest.  Currently, high yield savings accounts are getting (on average) about 5x money market accounts, so I would suggest a high yield savings account like ING Direct.


  1. says

    Hello! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could
    find a captcha plugin for my comment form?

    I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having trouble
    finding one? Thanks a lot!

  2. says

    Was initially in actual fact searching for just an ordinary shower enclosures when I stumbled upon this web site,
    didn’t even know there was such a thing as a ‘steam shower enclosure’, wow, may just may have to
    get one

  3. says

    Awesome steam showers, my family had a unit hooked up approximately 5 years
    ago and so it could possibly do with modernizing, never get a bland
    old traditional type of shower ever again

  4. says

    s password, then try to sign in to your Windows system and reset
    the forgotten windows password. It is possible to frequently go to a person’s Trade server
    aided by the mobile phone network, or possibly function traditionally, or simply cancel it
    logon. With the wireless off, battery life is up to 14 hours and up to approximately 4 hours for video or pictures, all of which is similar to earlier rumors and informal comments.

  5. says

    Although maximum site owners are familiar with these concepts, but they
    may lack the expertise to do it the correctly.
    As the culture of internet slang grew, it took on new origins from pop culture or video
    games and television. For more information visit: security gives you the protection from all kinds of worms, viruses and other

  6. says

    Like a pet owner, you may put your dog to work assisting you to shed
    weight. In fact, it is best for you long-term
    health to find a diet that gets you the maximum nutrients for the minimum calories.
    There are plenty of medical conditions that can contribute to weight gain.

  7. says

    Actor and singer Patrick Bruel has been certainly one of
    France’s biggest stars during the ’90s, first making his / her name as a teen idol
    and leading a return to traditional French chanson within the new millennium.

    Bruel was given birth to Patrick Benguigui within Tlemcen, Algeria, on May 14, 1959.
    His or her father abandoned the family unit when Patrick was only a year
    old, in addition to 1962, after Algeria acquired its independence, his mummy moved to France, negotiating inside the Paris suburb involving
    Argenteuil. A great soccer player in the youth, Patrick first chosen the idea of becoming a artist having seen Michel Sardou
    perform in 1975.

    As good luck could have it, acting would provide him his first success;
    first-time movie director Alexandre Arcady ran an advertising seeking a man using a French-Algerian (or “pied-noir” in German slang) accent for his
    motion picture Le Coup de Sirocco. Benguigui (as he was still
    called) responded and received the business. The below year,
    he spent a in Nyc, where he met Gérard Presgurvic, later
    to become his most important composer.

    Source: http://champions.ecircassia.com/?p=86

  8. says

    For those who were wondering, we were playing Black-Ops at the time we discussed this (the last real
    time I remember us consistently playing Call of
    Duty a few times out the week. With gold membership you can capitalize on one
    of the most truly unique features of Xbox Live subscriptions, and the reason they and many other online gaming experiences have
    become so remarkably popular-multiplayer gaming. The one thing that
    almost all enthusiasts agree on, and that has a firm scientific basis,
    is that the interaction between the sound waves produced by a loudspeaker, and the room the speaker
    is located in, can be crucial.

  9. says

    We absolutely love your blog annd find a loot of your post’s to be just what I’m looking for.
    can you offer guest writers to write content available for you?
    I wouldn’t mind writing a post or elaborating on a few of
    the subjects you write concerning here. Again, awesome web log!

  10. says

    FoxyMarket es una plataformas que permiten a los miembros comprar y
    vender licencias de
    elementos digitales como temas de sitios web, producción de
    música, archivos de proyectos
    gráficos en movimiento, código de software, vectores,
    imágenes y mucho, mucho más.
    El mercado facilita las transacciones entre nosotros, los compradores y los autores a través
    de un método de pago. http://www.foxymarket.com

  11. says

    This is the perfect site for anyone who really wants to understand this topic.
    You realize so much its almost tough to argue with you (not that I really will need to…HaHa).
    You definitely put a fresh spin on a subject which has
    been written about for a long time. Wonderful stuff, just wonderful!

  12. says

    Gingko Biloba has been used by the Chinese for centuries to treat various
    ailments and is now thought to be an effective natural treatment for tinnitus.
    Elderly patients tend to benefit from this treatment program but it can cover the gaps
    that are left by the alternatives which are unable to restore
    hearing. Tinnitus is an auditory hallucination, a noise abnormality that
    originates in the ear.

  13. says

    Some entrepreneurs make mistake of trying to setup business in a very
    scale disparate making use of their availability of funds and resources to invest
    in loans. There is also a lots of details about freelancing or telecommuting, but
    outside books and blogs, it can be hard to locate specific advice for the work from home business.
    This will be the best online affiliate marketing affiliate product for the net.

  14. says

    Fantastic goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you are
    just extremely great. I actually like what you have acquired
    here, really like what you are stating and the way in which you say it.

    You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it wise.

    I can not wait to read much more from you.
    This is really a tremendous site.

  15. says

    After all, the only indicator of you actual location is your IP.
    Sitting down in a circle, each person says (holding the champagne cork) “this is my
    pig, I love my pig, I kiss my pig on the ………,” each person says a different body part and you kiss the cork
    before passing it on. In the classic Barbie to Bratz or icons,
    these online dress-up games use a wide array of characters, dresses, shoes
    and accessories for you to mix and match.

  16. says

    Humana People to People makes their objective to advance under-developed countries through providing education to primary school lecturers and craftsmen, making an effort to promote good health and deliver information regarding Aids and also to help out with further increasing areas agriculture.
    Humana People to People takes on a number of different
    projects and tasks around poverty-stricken places in nations throughout
    the globe. Through employing the local persons and also their governing administration, they could support those people
    who are in need of funds via their non-profit aid agencies.
    China is just one of a number of nations the non-profit agency goes to face the important issues that
    they confront at present.
    The Humana People to People Movement works jointly with The
    Federation for Associations within the Yunnan province of China.

    The job started within 2005 and remains around today. The Humana People to People Co-operation Project Office of the Yunnan Province
    features to grow money to implement a variety of commissions
    all through the province within poverty-stricken locations.

    Some commissions that Humana People to People seeks to take to this particular area of China
    involve vocational education centers where they are able to advance their education, fixing
    them for work, offering information on infectious illnesses
    and more.

  17. says

    Electrical power along with commodity selling prices are assumed to be the
    lead to amid the improves. You are likely to have to apparent it all out
    sooner or later, so you may as well start at the base.

    But, compared with the normal sugar laden chocolate included raisins this coronary
    heart balanced possibility is almost nothing to come to feel guilty about indulging

  18. says

    Humana People to People creates their purpose to develop under-developed nations
    around the world through giving instruction to primary
    school instructors and artisans, helping promote health and give
    knowledge about Aids and to assistance in even more generating the
    places farming. Humana People to People represents a variety of different
    jobs and duties all through poor places in countries from around the world.

    Through employing the nearby men and women and governing administration, they can assist people who are in need
    of funds by their non-profit assistance institutions.
    China is one kind of lots of countries the non-profit
    agency goes to face the urgent concerns that they confront at present.

    The Humana People to People Motion works with The Federation for Organizations from the
    Yunnan area of China. The project began within 2005 and continues over
    currently. The Humana People to People Collaboration Assignment Agency of the Yunnan Area operates to improve money to be able
    to achieve numerous developments all through the area within poverty-stricken areas.

    A number of developments which Humana People to People works to bring to the current area of China involve business education centers where they could further their education and learning,
    preparing them for jobs, presenting facts
    about transmittable illnesses and more.

  19. says

    I was recommended this website bby my cousin. I am now nnot certain whether thiss publish is written through him as nobody else recognise such targeted aapproximately my difficulty.
    You’re wonderful! Thanks!

  20. says

    Found an awesome variable height table a week ago on the internet, but i’m still searching for
    it in a nearby showroom though in order to test it
    fully out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *